RACE IN LATIN AMERICA – IS IT BLACK AND WHITE?

When my family moved from North Jersey to South Florida in the late 80’s, I was a teenager.  We had a new, rich, Afro-Cuban neighbor who became good friends with my Afro-Cuban mom.  I recall that neighbor often saying to my mom, “Los negros somos la raza sufrida.”  Translation: “Blacks are the suffered race.”

That phrase confused me.  First of all, are we black?  And if we are, where’s this suffering our new neighbor was referring to?  I mean we both resided in this affluent, security-protected high-rise condo on the beach.

Over time, I kept thinking about that phrase as I observed the world around me.  Regarding the “suffering” component of that comment, I observed that yes, no matter the part of the world being discussed; there exists a correlation between depressed socio-economic standing and the black race.  The reasons for this marriage between these two factors are subject of much debate and focused study.  I won’t attempt to delve deeply into it now other than to declare I find the correlation to be valid.

As for the question, “are we black?” for me, the answer is yes, at least in part (I expand on this notion in a prior post titled, “I’m Not Black, I’m Hispanic.” 

Interestingly, it appears that the identification and meaning of one’s blackness is country-specific.  In the United States, one-drop of black blood and you’re black by most accounts.  However, throughout the world, the answer is not so “black and white.” 

Harvard Professor Henry Louis Gates, Jr. tackles the subject of black identity in his current PBS series “Black in Latin America.”  So far, he’s released video features on the Dominican Republic & Haiti, Cuba and Brazil.  Here’s my simplified interpretation of how this documentary explains how blacks in these countries reconcile their racial identity:

    • Dominican Republic – Due, in part, to their legacy of strife with their proudly black island neighbors, Haiti, Dominican’s generally resist the black label
    • Cuba – Afro-Cubans embrace their black race, but are Cubans first and foremost
    • Brazil – They proudly account for a multitude of color shades.  Brazilians aspire for a color blind democracy but it eludes them.

The next two countries Professor Gates will address are Mexico and Peru (episode premieres on Tuesday, May 10th at 8 PM EST on PBS).  It should be interesting to see how the narrative changes when the story of black identify is told from the prism of these Caribbean-centric nations to Central America (I realize that Brazil is non-Caribbean, but I view their cultural nuances to be more aligned with the Dominican Republic and Cuba than Mexico and Peru…I may be wrong).

Growing up in the United States, where the question of race and identity is simply boiled down to the “one-drop rule,” by studying Latin America, it is interesting to see how the story of race is characterized by such a broad spectrum of country-specific experiences.  I’m intrigued to know how the story changes, or not, when we explore the history of race and identity in non-Latin America countries.

If I were to run into my mom’s old Afro-Cuban neighbor today, I’d tell her that her notion that “los negros somos la raza sufrida” is interesting, perhaps somewhat true but definitely incomplete.

Reference: http://www.pbs.org/wnet/black-in-latin-america/
Advertisements

One comment

  1. I have come to the peaceful conclusion that the culturing of the United States on this topic – not that it cannot change, it instead simply resists change. People understand the cleanliness of the logic behind being a proud Latino of the Black race, but they simply choose – they prefer – to “territorialize” the subject (if you will) and make an attempt at imposing their rules upon us… equally cognizant of their true lack of authority in doing so.
    Societies have scary habits of writing “unwritten” rules about things that end up snowballing throughout generations in dangerous ways. This “one drop of black blood and you’re black” concept stems from slavery in so that there would be no confusion about the apparent “contamination” of the blood of a baby conceived via secret intimacy between white and black. Often times, the victimized baby would not even be told that they had white mixture. They’d grow old, die, and never know. And the more that even present-day African-Americans keep this “one drop of black blood” “rule” alive (think about why I just separated the quotes there), they’re tipping their hat to a hatred born out of slavery.
    It’s pathetic. Yet it’s exercised daily and proudly. And it’s encouraged.
    This ignorant behavior is this country’s preference. And I conceded that if I’m going to continue to live in this country, I’m going to have to simply accept it. I don’t have to agree with it, I simply have to accept it.
    Thank you for the PBS heads-up; I will watch.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s